Table 2 Comparison of anesthetic emergence quality and analgesic efficacy between groups
Group | ES1 group(n = 20) | ES2 group(n = 18) | H1 group(n = 19) | H2 group(n = 19) | P value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Extubation time(min) | 14.5[13.0-20.5] | 16.0[11.8–18.5] | 17.0[10.0–22.0] | 20.0[11.0–26.0] | 0.666 |
Awakening time(time) | 11.5[8.0-14.5] | 9.5[5.0-12.5] | 9.0[5.0–16.0] | 8.0[6.0–16.0] | 0.629 |
Choking cough at extubation, n/total N(%) | 2/20(10%) | 3/18(17%) | 2/19(11%) | 2/19(11%) | 0.897 |
Agitation at extubation(n), n/total N(%) | 9/20(45%) | 4/18(22%) | 2/19(11%) | 2/19(11%) | 0.041 |
Postoperative salvage analgesia, n/total N(%) | 5/20(25%) | 3/18(17%) | 2/19(11%) | 3/19(16%) | 0.700 |
The time of first PCA(min) | 70.0[60.0-100.0] | 75.0[60.0-87.5]* | 52.5[47.5–60.0] | 60.0[50.0–70.0] | 0.021 |
The total number of PCA compressions(times) | 3.0[2.0-4.3]* | 4.0[3.0–4.0]* | 8.0[5.0–8.0] | 5.0[4.0–6.0] | <0.001 |
The effective number of PCA compressions(times) | 3.0[2.0-4.3]* | 4.0[3.0–4.0]* | 8.0[5.0–8.0] | 5.0[4.0–6.0] | <0.001 |